By Ken Reed
In the end, this year’s American League East race might be decided by a blown call at first base this past Saturday night.
The New York Yankees and Baltimore Orioles have been battling for first place for weeks. The Orioles won Saturday’s game between the two teams when the Yankees’ Mark Teixeira was called out despite being clearly safe while sliding head first into first base on the back end of a double play attempt. Replays showed that Teixeira easily beat the ball to first but umpire Jerry Meals missed it and called him out.
“It was not a bang-bang play. He was safe. He was clearly safe,” Yankees manager Joe Girardi said. “You hate to lose a game that way, but he missed it.”
Teixeira was even more upset.
“I’m probably going to get fined,” railed Teixeira. “But I don’t care, really. I’m out there fighting. We are out there fighting. When you are battling like we are battling and they can’t get a call right, that pisses you off. It really does.”
The point here isn’t to focus on this particular blown call. This Major League Baseball season has had numerous blown calls. The point is that it’s time for Major League Baseball to expand its use of instant replay in order to get a much higher percentage of calls correct.
Blown calls negatively impact baseball history. Remember, it was only two years ago that the Detroit Tigers’ Armando Galarraga was robbed of a perfect game when umpire Jim Joyce blew a call at first base.
Managers should have the ability to challenge a limited number of calls per game via instant replay. Maybe they don’t need to throw out a red flag like head coaches do in the NFL but they need to have the ability to notify the home plate umpire that they’re challenging a particular call. Maybe you limit the number of challenges to two per game. Whatever the final rule change is, in this technological age, managers need the ability to challenge controversial baseball plays.
Apart from balls and strikes, every play in baseball should be subject for review: fair/foul calls down the lines, every play at every base, catch/trap calls on flyballs, etc.
Some baseball purists continue to argue that using instant replay more often will lengthen the games too much. I think the actual time impact would be minimal. Moreover, the use of instant replay would severely restrict the often long — and futile — arguments between managers and umpires.
There was resistance to move to instant replay reviews in the NFL but I think very few NFL coaches or fans would argue that the instant replay system isn’t working in the NFL today.
Like virtually all baseball fans, I like the tradition and nostalgia in baseball. But I’m also a fan of progress. And using more instant replay in Major League Baseball to get more calls right would definitely be a step in a positive direction.
– Ken Reed, Sports Policy Director, League of FansPrint
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Joseph Siprut
11 Apr 2013
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Fred Bowen
20 Feb 2013
Q & A with Legendary Sportswriter Frank Deford
27 Jan 2013
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Brenda VanLengen
28 Dec 2012
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Diana Cutaia
1 Nov 2012
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Patrick Hruby
28 Sep 2012
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Allen Sack
8 Aug 2012
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Donna Lopiano
5 Jun 2012
Q’s & A’s with Jim Thompson
14 May 2012
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Activists: Dave Zirin
18 Apr 2012
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Activists: William Dowling
27 Mar 2012
Q’s & A’s with Notable Sports Figures: Taylor Branch
9 Mar 2012
Q’s & A’s with Notable Sports Figures – Joe Nocera
27 Feb 2012
Q’s & A’s with Notable Sports Figures – Chris Nowinski
13 Feb 2012
Q’s & A’s with Notable Sports Figures: Joe Ehrmann
3 Feb 2012
Q & A With John Gagliardi
24 Jan 2012
Q & A With Robert Lipsyte
10 Jan 2012
Q & A With Jay Coakley
27 Dec 2011
Q & A With John Gerdy
9 Dec 2011
- Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Joseph Siprut
Special FeaturesFrom League of Fans
League of Fans is a sports reform project founded by Ralph Nader to encourage social & civic responsibility in sports industry & culture. See League of Fans Core Principles
April 6, 2013League of Fans Calls for More Humanistic Coaching Programs. Click here to see the release.
League of Fans Announces 2012 “Sport At Its Best” Awards
December 20, 2011 Click here to read the news release and report on Ralph Nader's Call for Budding Sports Reformers
December 7, 2011 Click here to read the news release and report on Ralph Nader's Claim that Sports Media Are Dropping the Ball on Social, Cultural, and Economic Issues in Sports
November 22, 2011 Click here to read the news release and report on the campaign to Make the NCAA Live Up to Its Stated Purpose
October 26, 2011 Click here to read the news release and report on the campaign to create a National Sports Commission
October 11, 2011 Click here to read the news release and report on the campaign to Ensure Equal Opportunity in Sports for all Americans
September 21, 2011 Click here to read the news release and report on putting the "Youth" back into "Youth Sports"
September 8, 2011 Click here to read the news release and report on the campaign to abolish the BCS and Establish a College Football Playoff
August 25, 2011
Read the news release and report on Mandatory Implementation of King-Devick Concussion Test in High School and Youth Sports
August 11, 2011
Click here to read the report and news release and about the campaign to promote sports and physical education for all students
Read the news release and report on Campaign to Promote Humanistic Coaching Education Programs
July 13, 2011
Read the news release and report on the Push For Community Ownership in Professional Sports
June 24, 2011
Read the news release and report and Sports Manifesto on Re-Launch of League of Fans
March 24, 2011
NCAA's Reaction to League of Fans' Proposal
March 29, 2011
League of Fans' Response to NCAA
March 25, 2011
League of Fans Proposes Eliminating Athletic Scholarships to Help Restore Integrity on College Campuses
League of Fans is a project of the Center for Study of Responsive Law.