Dallas Catch Reversal Latest Shameful NFL Decision
by Ken Reed
The NFL can’t seem to avoid controversy this season.
From the way they completely botched the Ray Rice and Adrian Peterson situations, to the brutal handling of the “pass-interference-no-pass-interference” play in the Detroit Lions-Dallas Cowboys playoff game (a review of the play showed there were actually three penalties against Dallas on the play and none of them were ultimately called), to yesterday’s debacle in the Green Bay-Dallas divisional playoff game when Dez Bryant’s amazing catch was overturned after a replay review.
I didn’t have a rooting interest yesterday but I was enjoying the drama of the Packers and Cowboys going at it in historic Lambeau Field when the referees stepped in and ruined the game (and ended Dallas’ season).
Anybody, and I mean ANYBODY, who has played football or watched it for any length of time could see that Bryant jumped, made an amazing two-handed catch, pulled the ball into his body, took three steps and reached for the goal line with the ball in his outstretched left hand when the ball came loose because of contact with the ground as Bryant tried to score a touchdown that would have given the Cowboys the lead on a gutsy fourth down call by Cowboys coach Jason Garrett. The ground can’t cause a fumble once the player has possession and Bryant clearly had possession.
The rule in question is called the “Calvin Johnson Rule,” named after the Lions’ receiver was ruled to have “not completed the catch” on a play in the end zone. (For the record, he did complete the catch. The NFL botched that play too.) The replay official in the Dallas-Green Bay game, and the game’s referee, Gene Steratore, determined that Bryant was still in the process of making the catch when he was reaching for the goal line. They said he didn’t make a “football move.” What?! Pulling the ball in, taking three steps and lunging for the goal line isn’t a “football move” these days?
Please. Who made up this infamous “Calvin Johnson Rule?” Surely it wasn’t anyone who’s played or coached the game. Was it some NFL bureaucrat in a back office somewhere?
Dez Bryant made an amazing catch on a late fourth quarter, fourth-down play in one of the league’s iconic football arenas yesterday. It was a play that deserves to be played over and over in coming NFL seasons. Instead it was erased from NFL history by a nonsensical rule — one that must be overturned in the offseason.
ESPN rules analyst and former NFL referee Jim Daopoulos said he’s not sure why the “Calvin Johnson Rule” exists, especially when it so blatantly goes against the eye test.
“I could go into a bar right now and ask 50 drunks whether it was a catch or not,” he said. “And those 50 drunks, whether they like Dez Bryant or they hate him, and no matter if they know the rules, will all say it should be a catch.” (See “Inside Slant: Post-Dez Bryant …”)
Well, then perhaps the NFL should use the “50 Drunks Test” on red flag calls instead of putting an NFL referee in the replay booth.
The one positive from this unfortunate ruling is the classy manner in which Bryant (somewhat surprisingly, given his volatile nature in the past), Garrett and Cowboys’ quarterback Tony Romo handled the situation after the game.
“I thought Tony Romo made a great throw, Dez made a great catch on the ball,” Garrett said. “Obviously it was ruled a catch at the outset. It looked like to me he had three feet down. What they describe to us all the time is ‘a move common to the game,’ and Dez reached out for the goal line like he’s done so many times. It’s a signature play for him. He maintained possession of it throughout, in my opinion.
“But let me make it really clear: This game wasn’t about the officiating. We had 60 minutes. We had an opportunity to come up here and win a football game, and at the end of the day we didn’t get that job done. That play was big in the game, but there were other plays in the game and unfortunately we didn’t do the things necessary to win the ballgame.” (See “Dez Catch Reversal …”)
Sportsmanship 1, Inane NFL Rule 0.
–Ken Reed, Sports Policy Director, League of Fans
Sports Forum Podcast
Episode #33 – League of Fans’ Sports Forum podcast: Ken Reed Announces His Retirement and Chats With League of Fans Founder Ralph Nader – Ken and Ralph talk about the history of League of Fans and the reasons it was created. They then move into a discussion of a variety of contemporary sports issues that League of Fans has been working on in recent years. Ken and Ralph end by talking about the need for sports fans, athletes, and other sports stakeholders to get involved in the sports reform movement and be activists and change agents on issues important to them, whether that be at the local, state, or national level.
Listen on Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and others.
Follow on Facebook: @SportsForumPodcast
More Episodes on Apple Podcasts; Spotify and others.
Episode #32 – League of Fans’ Sports Forum podcast: Prolific Author Joe Posnanski Joins the Show – Posnanski is one of America’s best sportswriters and has twice been named the best sports columnist in America by the Associated Press Sports Editors. We chat about his new book, “Why We Love Baseball,” his new Substack newsletter called Joe Blogs.
Episode #31 – League of Fans’ Sports Forum podcast: Foul Ball Safety Is Still an Important Issue at Ballparks – Our guests are Jordan Skopp, founder of FoulBallSafety.com and Greg Wilkowski, a Chicago based attorney. We discuss the historical problem of foul balls injuring fans and why some teams are still hesitant to put up protective netting in some minor league and college baseball parks.
Episode #30 – League of Fans’ Sports Forum podcast: The State of College Athletics with Dr. David Ridpath: Problems and Potential Solutions – Ridpath is a sports administration professor at Ohio University and a member of The Drake Group, a college sports reform think tank.
Episode #29 – League of Fans’ Sports Forum podcast: The Honorable Tom McMillen Visits League of Fans’ Sports Forum – McMillen is a former All-American basketball player, Olympian, Rhodes Scholar and U.S. Congressman. We discuss the state of college athletics today.
Episode #28 – League of Fans’ Sports Forum podcast: A Chat With Mano Watsa, a Leading Basketball and Life Educator – Watsa is President of PGC Basketball, the largest education basketball camp in the world. We discuss problems in youth sports today.
Media
"How We Can Save Sports" author Ken Reed appears on Fox & Friends to explain how there's "too much adult in youth sports."
Ken Reed appears on Mornings with Gail from KFKA Radio in Colorado to discuss bad parenting in youth athletics.
“Should College Athletes Be Paid?” Ken Reed on The Morning Show from Wisconsin Public Radio
Ken Reed appears on KGNU Community Radio in Colorado (at 02:30) to discuss equality in sports and Title IX.
Ken Reed appears on the Ralph Nader Radio Hour (at 38:35) to discuss his book The Sports Reformers: Working to Make the World of Sports a Better Place, and to talk about some current sports issues.
- Reed Appears on Ralph Nader Radio Hour League of Fans’ sports policy director, Ken Reed, Ralph Nader and the New York Times’ Tyler Kepner discussed a variety of sports issues on Nader’s radio show as well as Reed’s updated book, How We Can Save Sports: A Game Plan. Reed's book was released in paperback in February, and has a new introduction and several updated sections.
League of Fans is a sports reform project founded by Ralph Nader to fight for the higher principles of justice, fair play, equal opportunity and civil rights in sports; and to encourage safety and civic responsibility in sports industry and culture.
Vanderbilt Sport & Society - On The Ball with Andrew Maraniss with guest Ken Reed, Sports Policy Director for League of Fans and author of How We Can Save Sports: A Game Plan
Sports & Torts – Ken Reed, Sports Policy Director, League of Fans – at the American Museum of Tort Law
Books