A League of Fans Special Feature
Taylor Branch is a civil rights and presidential historian best known for his trilogy on Martin Luther King, Jr. and the civil rights movement. He won the Pulitzer Prize for the first part of that trilogy, Parting the Waters: America in the King Years, 1954-63. He also wrote The Clinton Tapes: Wrestling History With The President, among many other books, including Second Wind, which he wrote with basketball superstar Bill Russell. He also served as an editor with The Washington Monthly and Harper’s and was a columnist for Esquire magazine.
Sports have always been a sideline interest for Branch. His curiosity about why the NCAA seems to always be in perpetual scandal led him to conduct a survey history of college sports. Branch recently wrote a comprehensive feature article for The Atlantic summarizing this work entitled, “The Shame of College Sports,” in which he attacks the structure of big-time college sports and makes the case for paying college athletes.
Branch was interviewed by Ken Reed, League of Fans’ sports policy director.
Ken Reed: Do you think the plight of college athletes today is a civil rights issue?
Taylor Branch: It’s definitely a civil rights issue. The governance of college sports is a civil rights issue because the athletes are citizens and are being denied their rights by what amounts to collusion.
Colleges are telling football and basketball players they can’t get anything above a college scholarship. The athletes are being conned out of their rights.
We need modern abolitionists to fight this unjust and unstable system.
KR: What are your thoughts on the NCAA?
TB: The NCAA’s amateur ideals are contrived. The NCAA is unstable and unbalanced in a number of respects. They represent about 1200 schools but all their attention is on the big BCS schools. The NCAA is divided between the big-time football and basketball programs and everyone else. There’s a lot of financial infighting. The big schools resent the money from March Madness that’s paid to the smaller schools.
In terms of rules violations, the NCAA’s enforcement with the big schools is getting weaker and weaker because the NCAA is afraid the big-time conferences and schools will leave and form their own organization.
If you tell Ohio State you can’t be on TV, you’re talking about millions of dollars. OhioStateand the Big Ten wouldn’t stand for it.
Most of the harsh penalties today fall on the players, not the schools.
KR: When it comes to the challenge of college sports reform, where do we start?
TB: There are a lot of issues concerning the governance of college sports. Who are the stakeholders? What are their rights? Who’s stepping up to their responsibilities?
If we start by recognizing everyone’s rights, we can reform things fairly in college sports. We can’t deprive athletes of their rights, including the right to earn a livelihood.
This whole issue of the rights of college athletes is sitting there as the elephant in the room whenever the subject of college sports reform is brought up. My primary concern is the basic rights of these athletes.
KR: You believe college athletes have the right to seek pay for their services, correct?
TB: Absolutely. College athletes are both athletes and students. They have every right to seek pay as athletes.
If college athletes were at the decision-making table regarding how to run sports, along with administrators and faculty, we might have a more honest debate on the value of athletes to a university.
My basic belief is that players have rights to seek player compensation. They have the right to bargain for their own livelihood. There needs to be a players’ association. Student government structures could provide a model.
KR: Do you see the NCAA, and its member institutions, as hypocrites when it comes to college sports?
TB: Absolutely, they are hypocrites, especially when they use the term “student-athlete” to try and protect their idea of amateurism. I think it’s fundamentally dishonest the way the NCAA and these schools have taken advantage of athletes in college.
It seems to me we have to separate the student function and the athlete function, instead of fusing the two together. “Student-athlete” is such a dangerous confection. They are both students and athletes. To be either a student or an athlete in a good school is demanding. To do both well is a remarkable achievement.
KR: If the bigBCS schools start paying big-time football and men’s basketball players, what will happen to the rest of Division I schools?
TB: If universities have an honest discussion about college sports — with players, faculty, administrators, and board members at the table — it might lead to the de-emphasis of athletics at some schools. If some universities can’t keep up the pace at the highest level they can deemphasize sports.
It could lead to a reexamination of the role of sports in colleges. What are our priorities as a society? In some respects, sports have become more important than higher education. How much do we want sports to dominate what happens at our colleges and universities?
KR: Do you see theBCS conferences separating from the NCAA at some point?
TB: I think the bigBCS schools separating from the NCAA will ultimately happen. It will lead to some type of national association of big-time sports programs.
TheBCSsystem in Division I football is already run apart from the NCAA. If we ever get a playoff in Division I football, it won’t be run by the NCAA. If a future football playoff is run successfully, without the NCAA’s involvement, the same schools could turn around and say, “We could do the same thing in basketball,” and then create their own basketball tournament apart from the NCAA.Print
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Dr. Richard Lapchick
11 Sep 2014
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Dr. Bobbi Lancaster
13 Aug 2014
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Terri Lakowski
29 Apr 2014
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Jim Baugh
16 Jan 2014
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Brian Kitts
12 Nov 2013
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Paul Busch
9 Oct 2013
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Chuck Wilson
17 Sep 2013
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Tom McMillen
5 Aug 2013
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Sab Singh
13 Jun 2013
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Joseph Siprut
11 Apr 2013
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Fred Bowen
20 Feb 2013
Q & A with Legendary Sportswriter Frank Deford
27 Jan 2013
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Brenda VanLengen
28 Dec 2012
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Diana Cutaia
1 Nov 2012
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Patrick Hruby
28 Sep 2012
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Allen Sack
8 Aug 2012
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Donna Lopiano
5 Jun 2012
Q’s & A’s with Jim Thompson
14 May 2012
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Activists: Dave Zirin
18 Apr 2012
Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Activists: William Dowling
27 Mar 2012
- Q’s & A’s with Leading Sports Reformers: Dr. Richard Lapchick
Special FeaturesFrom League of Fans
League of Fans is a sports reform project founded by Ralph Nader to encourage social & civic responsibility in sports industry & culture. See League of Fans Core Principles
Petition from Baseball Fans Everywhere To Mariano Rivera
April 6, 2013League of Fans Calls for More Humanistic Coaching Programs. Click here to see the release.
League of Fans Announces 2012 “Sport At Its Best” Awards
December 20, 2011 Click here to read the news release and report on Ralph Nader's Call for Budding Sports Reformers
December 7, 2011 Click here to read the news release and report on Ralph Nader's Claim that Sports Media Are Dropping the Ball on Social, Cultural, and Economic Issues in Sports
November 22, 2011 Click here to read the news release and report on the campaign to Make the NCAA Live Up to Its Stated Purpose
October 26, 2011 Click here to read the news release and report on the campaign to create a National Sports Commission
October 11, 2011 Click here to read the news release and report on the campaign to Ensure Equal Opportunity in Sports for all Americans
September 21, 2011 Click here to read the news release and report on putting the "Youth" back into "Youth Sports"
September 8, 2011 Click here to read the news release and report on the campaign to abolish the BCS and Establish a College Football Playoff
August 25, 2011
Read the news release and report on Mandatory Implementation of King-Devick Concussion Test in High School and Youth Sports
August 11, 2011
Click here to read the report and news release and about the campaign to promote sports and physical education for all students
Read the news release and report on Campaign to Promote Humanistic Coaching Education Programs
July 13, 2011
Read the news release and report on the Push For Community Ownership in Professional Sports
June 24, 2011
Read the news release and report and Sports Manifesto on Re-Launch of League of Fans
March 24, 2011
NCAA's Reaction to League of Fans' Proposal
March 29, 2011
League of Fans' Response to NCAA
March 25, 2011
League of Fans Proposes Eliminating Athletic Scholarships to Help Restore Integrity on College Campuses
League of Fans is a project of the Center for Study of Responsive Law.